Skip to content
Founder TaxPartners

Section 431 Election Calculator: With vs Without

Put in what you paid for the shares, what they'd be worth without the restrictions, how much the restrictions cut that value, and what you expect to sell for. The tool works out the tax both ways using HMRC's own formula. The default figures are HMRC's worked example from its manual. General guidance only, not advice on your shares.

Calculator

Section 431 Election Calculator: With vs Without

Put in what you paid for the shares, what they'd be worth without the restrictions, how much the restrictions cut that value, and what you expect to sell for. The tool works out the tax both ways using HMRC's own formula. The default figures are HMRC's worked example from its manual. General guidance only, not advice on your shares.

How many restricted shares you're acquiring.

£

What you pay for each share. Founders at incorporation often pay the nominal value; enter 0 if the shares are given to you.

£

The unrestricted market value on the day you acquire the shares. Your valuation should give this figure.

%

The gap between the unrestricted value and the restricted value, as a percentage. In HMRC's example a £1 share is worth 75p with its restrictions, a 25% discount.

£

What you expect each share to sell for. The tool assumes all the restrictions fall away on that sale.

Where the income tax starts. A large charge rises through the bands as it grows, and a basic-rate taxpayer's CGT starts at 18%.

Tax saved by making the election
£185
With the election £1,360 in tax; without it £1,545
With election: income tax when you get the shares£400
With election: CGT on the sale£960
With election: total tax£1,360
Without: income tax when you get the shares£300
Without: value taxed as income when the restrictions lift (25% of the sale value)£1,250
Without: income tax on that£500
Without: employee NIC on that£25
Without: CGT on the sale£720
Without: total tax£1,545
Without: employer NIC the company pays (15%)£188

How it's worked out. With the election you pay income tax now on the unrestricted value less what you pay, and everything after that is a capital gain. Without it you pay income tax now on the restricted value less what you pay (nothing, if the restriction is a forfeiture that ends within 5 years), and when the restrictions lift, the share of the value that was never taxed is charged as income at that day's value: HMRC's formula in section 428 ITEPA 2003. Assumptions: all the restrictions lift on the sale and the sale is at full value; no National Insurance when you get the shares (shares in a private company usually aren't readily convertible then); NIC on the charge when the restrictions lift only if the shares are readily convertible at that point, with 15% employer NIC for the company on the same amount. Income tax sits on top of your other income from the bottom of the band you chose, and the personal allowance tapers above £100,000. For a basic-rate taxpayer the CGT assumes the whole £37,700 basic-rate band is free, with any income charged in the sale year using it first. The £3,000 annual exempt amount isn't deducted. With Business Asset Disposal Relief on, 18% applies to the first £1m of gain (assuming none of the limit is used) and 24% above it. From 6 April 2027 the lifetime limit is due to fall from £1 million to £500,000 (announced at Budget 2026, still to pass in the Finance Bill). Not covered: a partial election that ignores only some restrictions, elections made later under sections 425 or 430, and shares from an EMI option exercised at market value, which already count as having the election made. The election must be signed by you and your employer within 14 days of getting the shares. General guidance only.

Check your position with a startup tax specialist

A calculator gives you the shape of the answer. We confirm your exact figures, the reliefs you can claim, and what your business needs to file. No obligation, and we reply within 24 hours.

We'll only use your details to respond to your enquiry. We don't pass them to any other firm. See our Privacy Policy.

What the election changes, and when it's worth making

Restricted shares are shares with strings attached, such as leaver terms, vesting or limits on selling, that make them worth less than the same shares without them. When you get them through your job, or as a founder who is also a director or employee, the tax rules for employment-related securities apply. The election is a joint choice by you and your employer, made within 14 days of getting the shares, to be taxed on the full unrestricted value straight away (ITEPA 2003 s431). In return, nothing more is taxed as income later: all the growth is a capital gain when you sell.

Without it, you're taxed at the start only on the lower, restricted value. The part of the value the restrictions took off is never taxed at the start, so when the restrictions lift, usually on a sale, that same share of the then value is charged to income tax, with NIC where the shares are readily convertible. If you paid no more than the restricted value and the restrictions cut the value by 25% at the start, 25% of the value when they lift is taxed as income. HMRC's manual works through this at ERSM30420.

The election saves tax when the shares grow, because it moves that slice from income tax at 40% or 45% (plus NIC) into capital gains at 18% or 24%. It can cost more when the shares fall in value, because you've paid income tax on a value you never get back, and the fall only gives a capital loss. Where you paid the full unrestricted value at the start, as a founder can at incorporation when the shares are worth little more than their nominal value, there's nothing left to tax later either way. Signing the election then costs nothing and gives certainty if the value is ever questioned.

The deadline is fixed: the election may not be made more than 14 days after the acquisition, and it can't be revoked. It isn't sent to HMRC; you and the company each keep a signed copy. Shares from an EMI option exercised at or above the market value at grant are treated as having the election made already, so no separate form is needed.

Frequently asked questions

It's a joint election by the employer and the employee that the shares are taxed as if they had no restrictions when acquired. You pay income tax up front on the unrestricted market value less anything you pay, and no further income tax charge arises when the restrictions lift, so the later growth is a capital gain. It must be made within 14 days of the acquisition and is irrevocable.

The proportion of the value that wasn't taxed or paid for at the start. HMRC's formula (ITEPA 2003 s428) takes the unrestricted value at acquisition, deducts what you paid and anything taxed then, and divides by the unrestricted value. That fraction of the value when the restrictions lift is employment income. In HMRC's example, shares worth £1 unrestricted and 75p restricted, given for nothing, leave 25% untaxed, so 25% of a £5 value is taxed as income when the restrictions lift.

On the formula, nothing is taxed as income when the restrictions lift if you paid at least the full unrestricted value at the start, so the election and no election give the same tax. Signing one anyway costs nothing when the price equals the value, and it protects you if HMRC later argues the value was higher than you paid.

Yes, if the shares lose value. The election taxes the full value at the start as income, and if the shares are later sold for less, that fall only gives you a capital loss. The tool shows this when the sale price is below the starting value.

Only where the shares are readily convertible assets when the restrictions lift, which they usually are on a sale because arrangements exist for them to be sold. Then employee NIC applies (8% between £12,570 and £50,270, 2% above) and the company pays 15% employer NIC on the same amount.

Tell us about your startup situation and we will confirm your exact figures and the compliance steps that apply to you. No obligation.

We'll only use your details to respond to your enquiry. We don't pass them to any other firm. See our Privacy Policy.