Skip to content
Founder TaxPartners

Share scheme advice when EMI does not fit: CSOP, growth shares and unapproved options.

Not every company qualifies for EMI, and not every equity award takes option form. When a company has gross assets over the £120m limit or 500 or more full-time equivalent employees (the EMI limits since 6 April 2026), or carries on excluded activities, or an employee breaches the working-time requirement, the EMI route closes. The alternatives each carry different tax treatment and different design constraints. CSOP is the tax-advantaged fallback at up to £60,000 of options per employee (£120,000 from 6 April 2027, if the Budget change becomes law): no qualifying-company conditions as strict as EMI, but a lower per-person ceiling. Growth shares and unapproved options fall under general employment-related-securities rules: income tax, and NIC where relevant, on the value acquired above any amount paid. Choosing the right structure depends on the company's stage, the target exit valuation, and the tax consequences for the participants. All of these structures also carry annual ERS return obligations by 6 July.

£60,000
CSOP options per employee: the tax-advantaged fallback once EMI limits or qualifying tests are breached, with no qualifying-company conditions as strict as EMI. Due to rise to £120,000 from 6 April 2027 (announced, not yet law)
£250,000 / £6m
EMI limits from 6 April 2026: £250,000 per employee over 3 years and £6m of unexercised options across the company. Reach either and further grants have to use CSOP, growth shares or unapproved options
14 days
Section 431 joint-election window: both employer and employee must sign within 14 days of acquiring restricted securities or income tax risk accumulates

The challenges clients face.

Assuming EMI is available when the company has already breached a limit or test

Companies that have raised significant funding, grown their team, or moved into adjacent activities may have crossed the EMI qualifying thresholds without realising it. A company with gross assets above £120m, or with 500 or more full-time equivalent employees, cannot grant qualifying EMI options, and once £6m of unexercised EMI options are out across the company, further grants cannot qualify either. Granting options under the assumption of EMI eligibility when the tests have been breached results in non-qualifying grants, with income tax on exercise rather than CGT at exit.

Not knowing that CSOP is the tax-advantaged fallback once EMI is off the table

Once EMI is off the table, the Company Share Option Plan is usually where we look next, and since 28 October 2026 HMRC has also called it EMI2 (the legislation still says CSOP). CSOP allows up to £60,000 of options per employee (£120,000 from 6 April 2027, if the Budget change becomes law) and does not have qualifying-company conditions as restrictive as EMI. The options are granted at market value, and if they're exercised between 3 and 10 years after grant there's no income tax or NIC, just CGT when the shares are sold. It's easy to drift from EMI to CSOP without planning the switch, so our guide to when CSOP replaces EMI sets out the triggers.

Using growth shares or unapproved options without understanding the ERS tax treatment

Growth shares and unapproved options fall under general employment-related-securities rules: income tax, and NIC where relevant, arises on the value acquired above any amount paid. Unlike EMI, there is no exemption from income tax when an unapproved option is exercised. Growth shares only share in value above a threshold set when they are issued, so growth above the threshold is taxed as a capital gain on sale rather than as income when the shares are acquired, but the threshold must be correctly set. Unapproved options create an income tax charge on exercise on the spread between market value and exercise price.

Founders acquiring restricted securities without the section 431 election

Startup shares often come with restrictions: pre-emption rights, drag-along provisions, vesting schedules. Those make them restricted securities under the ERS rules. A section 431 joint election means tax is worked out on the unrestricted market value when the shares are acquired, so there's no income tax charge later when the restrictions come off. HMRC's manual sets out the conditions at ERSM30450: you (as the employer) and the employee make it jointly, on a form HMRC approves, no more than 14 days after the acquisition. It can't be made late and it can't be undone, so it's worth having the form ready before the shares change hands. Our guide to the 14-day election has the detail.

How we help.

Eligibility diagnosis and alternative structure selection

We assess why EMI does not fit (which limit or test is breached) and identify the right alternative: CSOP as the £60,000 tax-advantaged fallback (£120,000 from 6 April 2027, if the Budget change becomes law), growth shares designed with the right participation threshold, or unapproved options where no qualifying-company conditions apply. We model the tax consequences of each structure for the participants at realistic exit valuations so the comparison is on substance, not just on the structure name.

CSOP and growth-share setup and documentation

A CSOP option price can't be manifestly less than the shares' market value at grant, so the value needs settling first. You can ask HMRC's Shares and Assets Valuation team to agree it, and there's no form for CSOP: you write to SAV with a proposed value, 3 years of accounts before the valuation date (or whatever accounts a newly trading company has) and anything else relevant, such as plans to float. That's different from EMI, which uses form VAL231. We put the proposal together, deal with SAV's questions and prepare the option agreement. For growth shares, we work out where the threshold should sit, back the value up and prepare the papers for the new share class. Set the threshold too low against today's value and the employee has an income tax bill on day one; our guide explains how growth shares work.

Section 431 elections and ERS return management across all scheme types

We identify all restricted-securities awards requiring a section 431 election and prepare the election so it is signed within the 14-day window. We register all scheme types with HMRC and file annual ERS returns by 6 July for every arrangement, including nil returns where no events occurred.

EMI, CSOP, growth shares and unapproved options compared

How each one is limited and taxed, from the day it's granted to the day the shares are sold.

EMI, CSOP, growth shares and unapproved options compared
EMICSOP (EMI2)Growth sharesUnapproved options
Limit per employee£250,000 of options over 3 years; £6m across the company£60,000 of unexercised optionsNo HMRC-set limitNo HMRC-set limit
Tax when granted or acquiredNone on the grantNone, as long as the price isn't manifestly less than market valueIncome tax, and NIC where relevant, on anything paid below market value; a section 431 election within 14 daysNone on the grant
Tax on exerciseNo income tax or NIC if the price was at least market value at grantNo income tax or NIC if exercised 3 to 10 years after grantNothing to exercise: they're shares from the startIncome tax on the gap between market value and the price paid, and NIC where relevant
Tax on saleCGT; BADR at 18% if the option was granted at least 2 years before the sale and you've been an officer or employee throughout, with no 5% testCGT; BADR only if the usual 5% shareholding tests are met for 2 yearsCGT; BADR only if the usual 5% shareholding tests are met for 2 yearsCGT on growth after exercise; BADR only if the usual 5% tests are met for 2 years
EMI limits apply from 6 April 2026. Announced at Budget 2026 and still to pass in the Finance Bill: the CSOP limit rising to £120,000 from 6 April 2027, and the BADR lifetime limit falling from £1 million to £500,000 for disposals from the same date. Source: GOV.UK, Tax and Employee Share Schemes.

Example figures displayed. They show how the rules work, not your own position. Your outcome depends on your circumstances.

Common questions

The right alternative depends on why EMI is unavailable. If the company has crossed the gross-assets or FTE limits, CSOP at £60,000 per employee (£120,000 from 6 April 2027, if the Budget change becomes law) is the standard tax-advantaged fallback. If the company carries on excluded activities or the employee cannot meet the working-time test, growth shares or unapproved options may be more appropriate. Each has different tax treatment and we assess the right structure against the company's specific facts.

CSOP allows up to £60,000 of options per employee, measured at the market value at the date of grant. CSOP options granted at market value and exercised between 3 and 10 years after grant are free of income tax and NIC. The gain from exercise to disposal is subject to CGT. The £60,000 limit is per employee and is not reduced by any EMI options previously held. From 6 April 2027 the CSOP limit is due to rise from £60,000 to £120,000 per employee (announced at Budget 2026, still to pass in the Finance Bill). The same announcement removes the link the other way: today CSOP options count towards an employee's £250,000 EMI limit, and from 6 April 2027 they're due to stop doing so.

Both fall under general employment-related-securities rules. For unapproved options, income tax (and NIC where relevant) arises at exercise on the difference between the market value at exercise and the exercise price. For growth shares, the value when they are acquired should be low because the shares only participate in growth above the threshold; anything the employee pays below that value is taxed as employment income. Gains above the threshold from acquisition to sale are CGT. On a sale, Business Asset Disposal Relief at 18% needs the usual tests met for 2 years, including holding at least 5% of the shares and voting rights; EMI shares skip the 5% test where the option was granted at least 2 years before the sale. The BADR lifetime limit is due to fall from £1 million to £500,000 from 6 April 2027 (announced at Budget 2026, still to pass in the Finance Bill).

Whenever founders or employees acquire shares that are restricted securities, which in practice covers a lot of startup shares (pre-emption rights, drag-along, vesting). A section 431 joint election must be made within 14 days of acquisition. Without it, income tax can arise later if restrictions are lifted or varied, or the shares are sold while still restricted. With the election, tax is charged on the full unrestricted market value at acquisition and no further income tax arises when the restrictions come off.

Free consultation

Speak to a startup tax specialist.

Tell us about your situation and we will reply within 24 hours.

Book your free consultation

Step 1 of 2 · About you

Optional: a bit more detail (helps us prepare)