If your company has granted EMI options, three things follow: registering the scheme with HMRC, notifying each grant, and filing an annual Employment Related Securities (ERS) return by 6 July every year, including years in which nothing happened. Grant notifications run on the same deadline but they're a separate filing, at least until options granted from 6 April 2027. Miss any of them and there's a cost: penalties on the return, and the EMI tax advantages themselves on a late notification.
What you must file and by when
The return's due every year from the tax year of the first grant until the scheme ends, not just in years when options were granted or exercised, and a year with nothing to report still needs a nil return (gov.uk: submit your ERS return). Here's how the four filings line up.
| Obligation | Trigger | Deadline | Nil return required? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Register the scheme | Before first filing; one-off | By 6 July after the tax year the scheme was set up, and before the first grant notification | N/A |
| Annual ERS return | Scheme exists at any point in the tax year | 6 July following the tax-year end | Yes |
| Nil return | No events in the year but scheme still active | 6 July following the tax-year end | Yes, the nil return IS the return |
| EMI grant notification | Options granted during the tax year (a separate filing until grants from 6 April 2027) | 6 July following the tax-year end | N/A (no grants, nothing to notify) |
Want this checked against your specific situation?
Leave your details and a one-line summary. One of our specialists will come back to you, with no obligation.
Step 1: register the scheme (one-off)
Before you can notify a grant or file any return, the EMI scheme must be registered through HMRC's ERS Online Service. The company has to be registered as an employer and have the PAYE online service on its HMRC account first. Then you sign in, go to the ERS section, choose to register a scheme, pick EMI and complete the self-certification declaration. HMRC issues a scheme reference number online within 7 days, and you'll need it for every filing after that.
When's the registration deadline? HMRC says to register new tax-advantaged schemes by 6 July following the tax year they were set up, and in practice you can't notify an EMI grant without it. If you've been operating an EMI scheme without registering it, that's a gap to close straight away. Any grant notifications it's made late have to go to HMRC's share schemes team in writing with the reason, and if HMRC accepts you had a reasonable excuse, it'll explain the next steps.
Step 2: the annual ERS return
Every tax year from the year of the first grant until the scheme ends (whether or not anything happened), the company files an annual ERS return through the ERS Online Service. There's a sheet in the EMI template for each kind of event: adjustments, replacement options, releases, lapses and cancellations, and non-taxable and taxable exercises. A surrender of options goes on the release, lapse and cancellation sheet. Exercise rows ask for the actual market value (AMV) at grant and at exercise, and taxable exercises also ask for the unrestricted market value (UMV). Our guide to EMI option valuation covers how AMV and UMV are agreed with HMRC Shares and Assets Valuation.
The return must be filed by 6 July following the end of the tax year. The UK tax year runs from 6 April to 5 April; so the 2025/26 return was due by 6 July 2026, the 2026/27 return is due by 6 July 2027, and so on. One thing changes for that 2026/27 return: HMRC has published new versions of the end-of-year templates, and from 6 April 2027 it'll reject anything filed on the old ones, including late returns for earlier years (ERS bulletin 70).
Step 3: the nil-return trap
No exercises, no lapses, no adjustments, and a return's still due. If the scheme exists, you file, and a missed nil return carries the same penalty as any other missed return.
It takes a few minutes: you answer no when the service asks about reportable events. "We didn't do anything this year" isn't a reason to skip it, and the deadline's the same 6 July.
Step 4: EMI grant notifications
When options are granted, the company must tell HMRC about each grant through the ERS Online Service. For options granted on or after 6 April 2024 that's due by 6 July following the end of the tax year of grant (it was 92 days from grant before then), so it shares the annual return's deadline but it's a separate filing, not part of the return. Up to 30 employees you can enter the details online; above that you upload HMRC's notification template. Miss the deadline and you risk losing the EMI tax advantages for the company and the employees, so a late notification goes to HMRC in writing with the reason.
That's due to change. For options granted on or after 6 April 2027, the separate notification is due to go, and you'll report grants on the EMI annual return instead (announced at Budget 2025, still to pass in the Finance Bill). Grants made up to 5 April 2027 still need the separate notification by 6 July 2027.
The notification asks for the details you should have recorded at grant: the number of shares under option, the exercise price, the market value of the shares at grant and the option holder's details. Agreeing that value with HMRC first is voluntary. If you want it, the form is VAL231 on gov.uk, and an agreed value lasts 90 days; our VAL231 walkthrough covers the form, the EMI option valuation guide covers how the value's set, and the disqualifying events guide covers what can go wrong after the grant.
Step 5: late filing and penalties
Filing after 6 July makes the company liable to a £100 penalty. If the return's still outstanding 3 months after the deadline, it's liable to a further £300, and to another £300 at 6 months. Once it's more than 9 months late, HMRC can charge £10 a day for a period it sets in a notice (ITEPA Schedule 5 paragraph 57B; ETASSUM56070). A return with a material careless or deliberate error that isn't corrected can cost up to £5,000. Late nil returns are penalised the same way, and the company's responsible for filing on time without a reminder from HMRC.
If a return's been missed in a prior year, the right course is to file it late and then deal with the penalty. You can appeal within 30 days of the penalty notice, and a reasonable excuse counts if you file without unreasonable delay once it ends (though relying on someone else who let you down usually isn't one). Don't leave prior years unfiled.
What you need before you file
For an active year, have these to hand before you sign in. For a nil year you only really need the scheme reference.
| Item | Why it is needed | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Scheme reference number | Required to access the scheme on ERS Online | HMRC registration confirmation |
| Details of all grants in the year | The separate grant notification requires option count, exercise price, grant date, market value at grant and participant details | Internal option agreements / cap table |
| AMV at grant and at exercise (UMV too for taxable exercises) | The return asks for these values, plus HMRC's valuation reference if you agreed one | Valuation records, or the HMRC SAV agreement |
| Details of all exercises in the year | Exercises are reportable events even if they qualify for EMI CGT treatment | Internal exercise records |
| Details of releases, lapses, cancellations and adjustments | Each has its own sheet; the return asks whether each followed a disqualifying event | Internal option register |
| Participant employment details | National Insurance number and the employing company's PAYE reference for each option holder | HR / payroll records |
Read the disqualifying events guide before filing if any participant's employment situation changed during the year. A working-time breach, a leaver or a takeover can be a disqualifying event; that changes what you report, and it can change the tax on any exercise more than 90 days later.
Getting it filed
The procedure itself runs through HMRC's ERS Online Service. Sign in with the Government Gateway user ID you used to register the scheme, go to View schemes and arrangements, select the scheme and choose Submit annual returns for the tax year. Then fill in what's asked on screen and upload the completed template. You'll get a confirmation of receipt on screen and a submission receipt showing the date and time; download it, because it's your evidence of on-time filing. The service doesn't keep your return, so save the template too. To correct a return, you file a new one with all the right details, which replaces the first.
If you'd rather we handled the filing, or you're setting up EMI for the first time and want the registration, the valuation agreement and the first year's return done together, that's our EMI scheme setup service, with the yearly filing under core compliance. It earns its keep once you're making several grants a year, because each one has to be reported right.
New to EMI? The EMI scheme guide covers how it works, the qualifying-company tests and how it compares with other structures, and the funded startups hub shows where share scheme filings sit among everything else that lands after a raise.