Two steps in an EMI scheme catch founders out: the valuation and the annual filing. Set the valuation wrong and the income-tax-free treatment on exercise may not hold. Miss the 6 July deadline, even with a nil return in a quiet year, and you're into penalties, or worse if it's a grant notice. So here's what AMV and UMV actually mean, how long a value agreed with HMRC Shares and Assets Valuation lasts, and exactly what you file and when.
How EMI options are valued and why it matters
Before or at the point of grant, take the option value to HMRC Shares and Assets Valuation (SAV) and get it agreed. Two figures come out of that exercise: Actual Market Value (AMV), which fixes the exercise price at which no income tax arises on exercise, and Unrestricted Market Value (UMV), which ignores the restrictions and measures the EMI limits. Agreement's voluntary (SAV says you can grant without it), but skip it and HMRC can challenge the exercise price later, when your employees come to exercise.
The obligation sits with the company, not the employee. An incorrect or informally documented valuation tends to surface years later, and it's usually when employees are trying to exercise their options.
Actual market value vs unrestricted market value
They do different jobs, and HMRC Shares and Assets Valuation normally agrees both at once.
Actual Market Value (AMV)
AMV is the value of the shares as they actually are at the point of grant, taking into account any restrictions placed on them. Common restrictions include growth conditions, vesting cliffs, transfer limitations and leaver provisions. Because restrictions reduce what a willing buyer would pay, AMV is typically lower than UMV. AMV is the figure that sets the exercise price: if the exercise price is at or above AMV at grant, no income tax arises on exercise under EMI treatment.
Unrestricted Market Value (UMV)
UMV is the value of the shares ignoring all restrictions: the price a willing buyer and willing seller would agree if the shares were unrestricted. Because restrictions are stripped out, UMV is higher than AMV for any shares that carry meaningful conditions. UMV is the value that counts towards the limits: the £250,000 each employee can hold and the company's £6m total are both measured at UMV at grant (ITEPA 2003 Schedule 5, paragraph 5(6) and (7)). That's why it matters even though nobody pays it.
Worked example: AMV and UMV on a single grant
Say your shares would be worth £1.00 each with no strings attached, but the option shares carry leaver provisions and a vesting cliff. The figures are illustrative. Because a buyer would pay less for shares they cannot freely hold, SAV agrees a restriction discount, say 20%.
| Figure | Value per share (illustrative) | What it does |
|---|---|---|
| UMV (unrestricted) | £1.00 | Counts towards the £250,000 per-employee and £6m company limits at grant |
| Restriction discount agreed with SAV | 20% | Reflects the leaver and vesting conditions on the option shares |
| AMV (restricted) | £0.80 | Set the exercise price at £0.80 and no income tax arises on exercise |
So an employee exercising at the £0.80 AMV pays no income tax on exercise, and the £0.20 gap to UMV is what SAV signs off. The discount is never a fixed number: for a growth-share company where the ordinary shares sit above a hurdle, the gap between AMV and UMV can be far wider than 20%. Both figures have to be agreed with HMRC SAV on your actual share structure, not lifted from a rule of thumb. The same goes for UMV against your last funding round: it isn't a set percentage of the round price, and if investors bought preference shares with rights your ordinary shares don't carry, the option shares are valued on their own rights. For the limits, each option share counts at the £1.00 UMV, so a grant over 100,000 shares uses £100,000 of the employee's £250,000, not £80,000.
If your options are over shares that carry restrictions, read the section 431 election guide too: shares from a market-value EMI option get a deemed section 431 election, but a discounted option doesn't.
Calculator
EMI vs Unapproved Options Calculator 2026/27
Enter the option terms and exit value. The tool compares the employee tax cost and the company National Insurance cost across EMI, unapproved options and growth shares at 2026/27 rates. All outputs are general guidance; speak to a specialist before granting or exercising options.
The agreed actual market value per share (or per the whole grant) at the date of grant. Used as the EMI base cost and the growth-share starting point.
What the employee pays to exercise. For a clean EMI grant, this equals AMV. If below AMV, EMI still produces an income tax charge on the discount.
Value of the shares at sale or exit. Unapproved column assumes exercise and sale happen together (cashless exercise). For EMI, this is the disposal proceeds.
Sets where income tax on the unapproved exercise charge starts (20%, 40% or 45%, rising through the bands as the gain grows), and whether CGT starts at 18% (basic rate) or is 24% throughout (higher and additional rate).
The unrestricted market value of the growth shares when the employee gets them (usually a low hope value). Defaults to 0. With a s.431 election made within 14 days, income tax at acquisition is on this value less what the employee pays.
What the employee pays for the growth shares. Paying the full market value means there's no income tax at acquisition.
Your result
Your answer's ready. Press below to see it.
Agreeing the valuation with HMRC Shares and Assets Valuation
The process runs through HMRC's SAV team, and you start it on form VAL231, which is live on gov.uk as an online print-and-post form. Older guides that say it's gone are out of date. Our VAL231 walkthrough takes you through the submission, and the scheme rules themselves are in the HMRC EMI guidance and the ERS service pages.
Both values rest on the same evidence, and it's what SAV weighs:
- A description of the company's share structure and any restrictions attaching to the option shares
- Recent financial accounts or management accounts
- Details of any recent arm's-length transactions in the company's shares
- An explanation of any valuation methodology applied
Once HMRC SAV agrees the AMV and UMV, you have a defensible basis for the exercise price on each grant. The agreed values are used when completing the ERS return (see below). An agreed value lasts 90 days from the date of agreement, as long as nothing changes that might affect the share value before you grant (SVM110050). Grant after that and you'll need a fresh application, and if circumstances change materially inside the 90 days, seek a fresh agreement before the next grant rather than relying on the older figure.
Want this checked against your specific situation?
Leave your details and a one-line summary. One of our specialists will come back to you, with no obligation.
Why the valuation is the compliance linchpin
A wrong or undocumented valuation puts the whole scheme at risk. The income-tax and NIC advantages of EMI depend on the exercise price being set at or above AMV at grant. If HMRC disagrees with the valuation on enquiry, the difference between your exercise price and the true AMV at grant becomes a taxable employment income charge, with NIC on top where the shares are readily convertible assets.
It's a failure we see in inherited EMI schemes: the options were granted with an informally documented valuation, years pass, the company raises a funding round that crystallises value, and employees discover on exercise that the price was set incorrectly. The retrospective fix is difficult and expensive.
Agreeing the value with SAV at the start takes a little time, but it settles the exercise price before anyone relies on it. If you're not yet sure the company passes the EMI qualifying tests, check that first. See our EMI vs unapproved options calculator to compare the tax outcomes under a correctly valued EMI grant versus an unapproved option.
Registering the scheme and the annual ERS return
Before you can notify a grant or file a return, the EMI scheme must be registered with HMRC through the Employment Related Securities (ERS) service. Registration's a one-time step, but the obligations that follow are annual. Every registered scheme must file an ERS return by 6 July after each tax year end, regardless of whether any events occurred during that year. A nil return is required where nothing happened. Our EMI annual return walkthrough takes you through the filing itself.
The ERS return covers:
- Exercises, releases, lapses, cancellations, adjustments and replacement options during the year
- Details of any valuations agreed with SAV (HMRC's valuation reference)
- Grants too, for options granted from 6 April 2027 (announced at Budget 2025, still to pass in the Finance Bill); until then each grant goes on its own separate notification
Source: HMRC guidance on ERS returns.
Compliance timeline
| Step | Action | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Before or at grant | Agree AMV and UMV with HMRC Shares and Assets Valuation (SAV) | EMI guidance |
| Before the first notification | Register the EMI scheme via the ERS online service | ERS guidance |
| At grant | Issue option certificates with agreed AMV exercise price | EMI guidance |
| 6 July after tax year end | File annual ERS return (including nil return if no events occurred) | ERS guidance |
| 6 July after tax year of grant | File EMI grant notification (same 6 July deadline as ERS return; for grants from 6 April 2027, due to move onto the return) | ERS guidance |
The 6 July grant notification deadline
EMI grant notification must be filed with HMRC by 6 July following the end of the tax year in which the grant was made, the same day the annual ERS return is due. A grant made at any point in the 2025/26 tax year (6 April 2025 to 5 April 2026) must be notified by 6 July 2026. A grant made in 2026/27 must be notified by 6 July 2027. Source: HMRC ERS guidance.
The date's in the statute: for an option to qualify, notice of it has to be given to HMRC on or before 6 July following the end of the tax year of grant (ITEPA 2003 Schedule 5, paragraph 44(1)), through the EMI notification service. That's due to change for options granted on or after 6 April 2027: the separate notification goes, and you'd report those grants on the EMI annual return instead (announced at Budget 2025, still to pass in the Finance Bill). Grants made before then still need their own notice.
What you file and when
| Event | Obligation | Deadline | Nil return required? |
|---|---|---|---|
| EMI option grant | Grant notification through the ERS online service (separate from the return) | 6 July after tax year of grant | N/A (event did occur) |
| No events in year | Nil ERS return | 6 July after that tax year end | Yes, mandatory |
| Option exercise | ERS return including exercise details | 6 July after tax year of exercise | N/A (event did occur) |
| Option lapse | ERS return including lapse details | 6 July after tax year of lapse | N/A (event did occur) |
The nil-return requirement catches many founders off guard. Once a scheme is registered, the filing obligation persists every year until the scheme is formally closed, even in years when no grants, exercises or lapses occurred. A missed nil return is a late return like any other: £100, then £300 more at 3 months and again at 6 months, and up to £10 a day after 9 months (ITEPA 2003 Schedule 5, paragraph 57B).
What happens if you miss notification or use a stale valuation
Missing the 6 July notification deadline
Late grant notification costs the EMI tax treatment for the affected grants, because the notice has to be given on or before 6 July following the end of the tax year of grant for the option to qualify (ITEPA 2003 Schedule 5, paragraph 44(1)). The options are then taxed as unapproved options, which means income tax on exercise, and NIC too where the shares are readily convertible assets, rather than the CGT treatment available under EMI. HMRC penalties for late ERS returns are a separate risk, and they're the company's. Source: HMRC ERS guidance.
Using an undocumented or incorrectly set valuation
If the exercise price was set without an agreed SAV valuation and HMRC considers the true AMV to have been higher, the difference becomes a taxable employment income charge on exercise. That can mean a significant income tax bill for an employee who exercised expecting only a CGT liability, and where the shares are readily convertible assets, employee and employer NIC on top. Source: HMRC EMI guidance.
Using a stale valuation after material change
If a funding round, acquisition offer or other event has materially changed the company's value since the SAV agreement, the old agreed figure may no longer reflect AMV at the point of the new grant, and an agreed value only lasts 90 days anyway (SVM110050). Making a new grant using an outdated valuation carries the same risk as using no valuation at all: HMRC can assert that the true AMV at grant was higher than the exercise price. Seek a fresh SAV agreement before each new grant where circumstances have changed.
Getting valuation and notification handled
The valuation and the filings both start from the same information: your share structure, the restrictions on the option shares and up-to-date accounts at each grant. Getting it right at grant is much cheaper than fixing a mis-valued scheme when employees come to exercise.
Our EMI scheme setup service covers the full sequence: agreeing AMV and UMV with HMRC SAV, registering the scheme, drafting option certificates and keeping the annual ERS filing on track. Once the scheme is running, we handle the 6 July deadline, including nil returns in quiet years.
Still checking whether your company qualifies? Start with the EMI qualifying company rules guide. Worried about events that might affect existing options? The disqualifying events guide covers the traps and the 90-day window. For funded founders whose shares carry restrictions, the section 431 election guide is also relevant, and the funded startups hub covers what else needs filing once you've raised.