The cruel irony of EMI is that the events that strip it away are often the ones you've been working towards: a funding round that hands control to another company, an acquisition offer, a reorganisation of your share classes. Each can be a disqualifying event, and from the next day the option holder has 90 days to exercise with the EMI relief intact. Miss that and the growth in value after the event is taxed as income, and often the holder finds out too late to act.
What a disqualifying event is and why it matters
A disqualifying event is one of a short list of changes, set out in ITEPA sections 534 to 536, that happens while an EMI option is still unexercised. Under the EMI rules, the company has to stay independent and keep meeting the trading activities requirement, and the employee has to keep meeting the employment and working-time requirements. The size tests are different: they're checked on the day of grant only.
The event doesn't cancel the option, and it doesn't wipe out the relief on the spot. What it does is start a clock. If the option's exercised more than 90 days after the event, the growth in value after the event is charged as employment income rather than left to capital gains tax.
That's the saving mechanism. Exercise within the 90 days and the option keeps its EMI treatment in full, including any growth between the event and the exercise. Exercise later and the value built up before the event still keeps its relief; only the growth after it is taxed as income.
The point is that it's knowable in advance. If your company has EMI options live, you should know which corporate moves would trigger it before you make them, not discover it when an employee tries to exercise.
Company-level disqualifying events
The legislation lists three (ITEPA s534): another company taking control, the company no longer meeting the trading activities requirement, and a company that was only preparing to trade when it granted the options not starting that trade within two years. Two tests founders often worry about, gross assets and headcount, aren't on the list, because they're tested only on the day of grant.
Loss of independence
An EMI company mustn't be a 51% subsidiary of another company (more than 50% of its ordinary share capital owned by that company) or under the control of another company (on its own or with people connected to it). If an investor, acquirer or new group structure puts it there, that's a disqualifying event. Control means the power to make sure the company's affairs are run the way that person wants, usually through votes or the right to appoint the board. If a fund set up as a limited partnership takes control and its general partner is a company, HMRC treats that company as having control (ETASSUM52030). So review the EMI position before any funding round that shifts voting control, not just before a formal sale.
Breach of the gross-assets test (new grants only)
The EMI company must have gross assets of no more than £120m at the time of grant (£30m for a specified Northern Ireland company, and £30m for options granted before 6 April 2026). It's a grant-date test, so crossing the line later isn't a disqualifying event: options you've already granted keep their EMI status, but you can't grant new ones while you're over. A company whose balance sheet grows through asset acquisition, IP capitalisation, or cash raised but not yet deployed can get close quickly, so check the consolidated figure across the group before each grant.
Reaching 500 full-time-equivalent employees (new grants only)
The EMI qualifying conditions require the company to have fewer than 500 full-time-equivalent employees on the day an option is granted (250 for a specified Northern Ireland company; 250 was also the limit for options granted before 6 April 2026). Going over it stops new EMI grants but doesn't disqualify the options already granted. For a fast-hiring company the limit can arrive sooner than you'd think if headcount's tracked loosely. FTE is the measure, not headcount: someone working 21 hours against a 35-hour week counts as 0.6.
Starting an excluded activity
Certain activities are excluded from EMI, including property development, financial activities, and farming. If they grow into a substantial part of what the company or group does, it stops meeting the trading activities requirement, and that is a disqualifying event (ITEPA s534(1)(c)). HMRC normally accepts that excluded activities making up no more than 20% of the trade aren't substantial (ETASSUM52105). If you're expanding into an adjacent market, check the new activity against the excluded list before launch.
Employee-level disqualifying events
Employee-level events affect one option holder rather than the whole option pool. They're triggered when that person stops meeting the employment or working-time conditions attached to their options.
Failing the working-time requirement
An EMI option holder must meet the working-time requirement: working for the qualifying company (or a qualifying subsidiary) for at least 25 hours a week or, if less, at least 75% of their total working time. Someone who moves to a part-time role or takes on substantial consulting work outside the company may fall below it. There's also a deemed event at the end of a tax year if their average weekly time fell short over the year, though time off for illness, parental leave, reasonable holiday or garden leave still counts (ITEPA s535). Leavers who stay on the cap table as option holders but aren't employed by the company fail the test too.
Ceasing to be employed by the qualifying company
If the option holder leaves employment at the qualifying company, that's itself a disqualifying event. Leaver provisions in the option agreement govern what happens to unvested options, but for vested EMI options the tax result still turns on whether the holder exercises within 90 days of the day they left.
Option-level and structural events
Beyond company and employee conditions, some changes to the option itself or to the shares it's over can be disqualifying events (ITEPA s536). So can granting the holder a CSOP option that takes their unexercised CSOP and EMI options over the £250,000 limit; that interaction between the two limits is due to go from 6 April 2027 (announced at Budget 2026, still to pass in the Finance Bill).
Variations to option terms
Changing the terms of an EMI option (for example, the exercise price, the vesting conditions, or the class of shares it's over) is a disqualifying event if the change increases the market value of the shares under option, or means the option no longer meets the Schedule 5 requirements. HMRC can also treat a change to an option's fundamental terms as releasing the old option and granting a new one, which then has to qualify on its own. So have any variation to an existing EMI option agreement checked for its EMI impact before it's signed.
Share reorganisations and exchanges
An alteration of share capital is a disqualifying event where it creates, varies or removes a right or restriction on shares, affects the value of the shares under option, and either means the option no longer meets Schedule 5 or increases that value where it isn't made for commercial reasons or a main purpose is to increase it (ITEPA ss536 and 537; HMRC's summary is at ETASSUM57110). Converting the shares under option into another class is one too, unless a whole class converts into one other class and the company is employee-controlled or the majority of that class isn't held by directors and employees (s538). Share-for-share exchanges, which come up on a company flip or a new holding company, need particular care. A section 135 TCGA share-for-share exchange isn't itself a disposal for CGT purposes, but it's subject to the section 137 anti-avoidance test. On the options side, the new company can grant qualifying replacement options within the Schedule 5 time limits (usually 6 months after it gets control), and then the change of control isn't a disqualifying event. If the shares under option are restricted, read our guides on growth shares explained and section 431 elections.
The tax-consequence window
A disqualifying event doesn't make the option worthless, and the tax advantage doesn't vanish straight away. If the option's exercised within 90 days, it's taxed as an EMI option in full: for an option granted at market value, there's no income tax or NIC on exercise. If it's exercised later than that, income tax is charged on the growth after the event, that is, the market value at exercise less the market value immediately before the event (ITEPA s532(2)). NIC is due on it too where the shares are readily convertible assets (ETASSUM57060). The growth up to the event keeps its relief either way.
The window is 90 days for every disqualifying event. The statute's test is whether "the option is exercised later than 90 days after the day on which the event occurred" (ITEPA s532(1)(b)), and the day count doesn't depend on the type of event; HMRC's list of events in ETASSUM57050 uses the same 90 days for all of them. Count from the day after the event: an event on 1 March gives you until 30 May. From 6 April 2027 that window after a disqualifying event is due to extend from 90 days to 180 days, for events on or after that date and for existing options too (announced at Budget 2026, still to pass in the Finance Bill). Until then, plan on 90.
Here's how the numbers work on a takeover, per share.
Illustrative timeline: acquisition trigger and exercise
| Date | Event | Tax position (illustrative) |
|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | Company grants EMI option at an exercise price of £1 per share, agreed with HMRC Shares and Assets Valuation as the market value | No income tax or NIC on grant (EMI advantage applies) |
| Year 3 | Acquirer takes a controlling interest in the company (loss-of-independence event). Shares are independently valued at £10 per share immediately before it. | Disqualifying event occurs. The 90-day clock starts the next day. Nothing is taxed yet. |
| Within 90 days of the event | Option holder exercises at £1 per share while the shares are still worth £10. Shares are then sold. | No income tax or NIC on exercise. The £9 gain (exercise price to event-date value) is a capital gain on sale, potentially eligible for BADR at 18% if the option was granted at least two years before the takeover (after a disqualifying event, the two years run to the event, not the sale). Any growth after exercise is also a capital gain. |
| More than 90 days after the event | Option exercised at £1 when the shares are worth £14. | Income tax (and NIC if the shares are readily convertible) on £4, the growth after the event (£14 less £10). The £9 of growth up to the event isn't charged to income tax. The CGT base cost becomes £5 (£1 paid plus £4 taxed as income), and BADR's EMI route is no longer available. |
These figures are illustrative only. What's actually due depends on the facts, the timing of exercise, whether the option was granted at a discount and whether the shares are readily convertible. Speak to an adviser before exercising.
BADR and CGT on eventual sale
If you've exercised within the window and kept the shares, the eventual sale of those shares engages the CGT rules. The two rates on share disposals are 18% within the basic-rate band and 24% above it.
EMI shares carry a CGT advantage on sale that's easy to underrate. They qualify for Business Asset Disposal Relief (BADR) at 18% where the option was granted at least two years before the sale, and they skip the 5% personal-company test that non-EMI shares have to clear, against a £1m lifetime limit. From 6 April 2027 the lifetime limit is due to fall from £1 million to £500,000 (announced at Budget 2026, still to pass in the Finance Bill). So an employee who sells their EMI shares two or more years after the grant can reach BADR without ever owning 5% of the company, which is the very ceiling that would shut a typical startup employee out of the relief on ordinary shares.
So when do EMI shares lose their BADR? In two ways that matter here. If the option was exercised more than 90 days after a disqualifying event, the shares aren't "relevant EMI shares" any more and the EMI route to BADR goes (TCGA s169I(7E)), leaving only the ordinary 5% test. And the EMI route also needs the holder to have been an officer or employee of the company or group throughout the two years before the sale. But where a disqualifying event came first and the option was exercised within the 90 days, both two-year tests run to the date of the event instead (TCGA s169I(7Q)). So someone who exercises within 90 days of leaving can still qualify through the EMI route when they sell later, provided the option was granted at least two years before they left. Someone who exercised while employed and then left, with no disqualifying event before exercise, has to meet the test to the date of the sale, so they generally won't. To model the difference between exercising under an EMI scheme and outside it, use the EMI vs unapproved options calculator.
Calculator
Founder Exit Tax Estimator: Selling Before or After April 2027
Put in your gain, your share type and the BADR you've already used. You'll see the CGT if you sell before 6 April 2027, the CGT if you sell on or after it with the £500,000 limit announced at Budget 2026, and what Founders' Relief, still a proposal, would charge.
What you'll get for the shares less what they cost you (including any amount already taxed as income when you got them). The tool assumes you've no other gains in the tax year.
This changes which BADR conditions the result restates, not the maths. EMI shares don't need the 5% personal-company test; ordinary and growth shares do.
The total of gains you've claimed Business Asset Disposal Relief on in earlier sales. They count against the £1 million limit now and, as announced, against the £500,000 limit too.
Sets the headline figure; you'll see both dates either way. For CGT, a sale under an unconditional contract happens when the contract's made, not when it completes.
For a basic-rate taxpayer the tool assumes the whole £37,700 basic-rate band is unused. BADR gains use the band first, so it only changes the figures when part of the gain falls outside BADR and the BADR part is smaller than the band.
Your result
Your answer's ready. Press below to see it.
Disqualifying event map
| Event | Level | Immediate effect on the option | Action to consider |
|---|---|---|---|
| Another company acquires control (loss of independence) | Company | Disqualifying event; growth after the event date is taxed as employment income if the option is exercised more than 90 days later | Consider exercising within 90 days, or replacement options from the buyer; take specialist advice before the window closes |
| Gross assets exceed £120m | Company | Not a disqualifying event; options already granted keep EMI status, but no new grants while over the limit | Monitor balance sheet against the £120m threshold; consider CSOP as a fallback for new grants |
| FTE headcount reaches 500 | Company | Not a disqualifying event; no new EMI grants from this point | Track FTE carefully as you scale; assess CSOP for hires once you're at 500 |
| Company begins an excluded activity | Company | Disqualifying event once excluded activities are a substantial part of the trade | Review new business lines against the excluded-activities list before launch |
| Employee fails the working-time requirement | Employee | That holder's EMI options affected from the date the requirement is first missed, or from the end of a tax year when average hours fell short | Review before changing an option holder's hours or role; consider whether exercise before the change is appropriate |
| Employee leaves the qualifying company | Employee | Disqualifying event; leaver provisions in the option agreement govern unvested options | Vested options: exercise within 90 days of leaving to keep full EMI relief; report on the ERS return |
| Option terms are varied | Option | Disqualifying event if the change increases the value of the shares under option or means the option no longer meets Schedule 5; a change to fundamental terms can be treated as a release and re-grant | Take advice before varying any EMI option terms; document the rationale and whether the change is permitted |
| CSOP option takes the holder over £250,000 | Option | Disqualifying event for that holder's EMI options | Add up unexercised CSOP and EMI options before any CSOP grant |
| Share reorganisation or exchange | Option / structural | Depends on structure; a qualifying share-for-share exchange under s.135 TCGA may not be a disposal but is subject to s.137; replacement options granted within the Schedule 5 time limits avoid a disqualifying event | Model the exchange structure early and take HMRC clearance where available; don't assume a share-for-share preserves EMI status without advice |
Want this checked against your specific situation?
Leave your details and a one-line summary. One of our specialists will come back to you, with no obligation.
Reporting the event and next steps
The company reports disqualifying events to HMRC on the EMI end-of-year return within the Employment Related Securities (ERS) online service. The ERS return is due by 6 July after the end of the tax year. Where an adjustment, a release, lapse or cancellation, or a taxable exercise follows a disqualifying event, the template asks which of eight types of event it was (HMRC's EMI end-of-year guidance notes). Nil returns are required even when nothing's happened in the year. A late return makes the company liable to a £100 penalty, with more after 3 and 6 months, and getting the event wrong can complicate the option holder's tax position at exercise or sale.
If you're operating an EMI scheme and you think a disqualifying event may have happened, the steps are:
- Identify the date the qualifying condition was first breached. That is the event date for all purposes.
- Work out each affected option holder's 90-day deadline and whether they want to exercise before it passes.
- Ensure the event is captured on the next ERS return (or an amended return if the annual deadline has already passed).
- If the company is approaching the 500 FTE or £120m gross-assets thresholds, consider whether CSOP would be the appropriate vehicle for future grants. CSOP carries a lower £60,000-per-employee ceiling (£120,000 from 6 April 2027, if the Budget change becomes law) but stays open to companies that have outgrown the EMI size tests.
If you've got a live case, particularly one involving a funding round, an acquisition or a change to someone's hours, speak to us before the 90 days run out. The EMI scheme setup and advisory service covers both new grants and the ongoing compliance of existing schemes, including disqualifying-event triage.
The tests themselves are in EMI qualifying company rules, agreeing the value at grant is in EMI option valuation, and the fallback scheme is in EMI vs CSOP. Funded startups running equity schemes as part of a broader cap-table strategy can find the full picture at our funded-startups hub.