If HMRC has written to say it's checking your R&D claim, that's a compliance check: it wants you to show the claim's right. Usually that comes down to explaining, in plain language, what advance you were after, what was uncertain and why a competent professional couldn't simply have worked it out. A check isn't a finding that the claim's wrong. Reply on time, through one person, with the people who did the work, and a sound claim can come through intact.
What a compliance check on an R&D claim is
A compliance check is HMRC checking you're paying the right tax and getting the right reliefs.1 For an R&D claim on a Corporation Tax return, it's usually an enquiry into the return or the claim. HMRC will tell you what it needs at the start. It can ask you to:
- send information or documents
- meet to talk through your records (you can choose not to)
- let an officer visit your business premises
If you can't agree, HMRC can use its legal powers, and you can't ignore an information notice once it's given one.1 In an R&D enquiry, officers may also ask to talk to your management and technical experts, and they'll ask for what they need to confirm your projects are R&D under the government's guidelines and your costs qualify. HMRC says it'll keep its requests to the minimum it needs and ask for everything as early as it can.3
Want this checked against your specific situation?
Leave your details and a one-line summary. One of our specialists will come back to you, with no obligation.
Why HMRC looks at a claim
Every company tax return goes through a risk assessment.3 HMRC's manual lists the risk factors its officers weigh on an R&D claim.4 Among them: there's no analysis of how the relief was arrived at; the trade is one where it's less obvious how scientific or technological uncertainty would come in; the company's solvency would make an incorrect payable credit hard to recover; and costs called R&D in the accounts aren't the same as R&D for tax.
It also lists common errors. First on that list is project activity outside the scope of R&D for tax purposes. Then there's expenditure outside the qualifying categories, staff costs for people who aren't employees, overheads claimed as consumables, and connected-party rules not applied.4 For a software company, the first one usually means routine development swept into the claim. Our guide to what software R&D actually qualifies sets out where HMRC draws the line.
Will HMRC still pay the credit?
HMRC's own guidance says payable credit claims "should be dealt with quickly", because for some companies, small start-ups in particular, the cash can make the difference between success and failure. Where it's opened an enquiry without paying, the officer should keep under review whether at least a partial payment is possible.2
HMRC publishes its aims for this, and they're aims, not promises. Its practice note says: "Our aim is to pay 85% of payable tax credits within 40 days or contact you regarding the claim within 40 days." And: "If we decide not to make a payment because we think the claim may be incorrect, we will aim to open an enquiry within 60 days of receiving the claim." HMRC adds that it may change the first aim for a while when claim numbers rise, and that the aims don't replace the statutory time limits for enquiries, so it can pay you and still enquire later.3
What HMRC will ask you
Not every question applies to every claim, but here's what HMRC would normally ask the company to explain in plain language:2
- what advance in science or technology you were seeking
- what the R&D project was, and the bigger commercial project around it
- the scientific or technological uncertainties you had to resolve
- how the project went beyond what was already known
- why the answer wasn't readily deducible by a competent professional in the field
- when the uncertainties were overcome
- which activities count as R&D for tax purposes
Your Additional Information Form already answers some of this, so start there: the officer reviewing your claim has it in front of them.3 For the costs, HMRC will want to see which employees worked on the R&D and for what share of their time. The courts have said you can't start from "everything's R&D" and strip out the obvious exceptions, and that oral evidence may be accepted where written records are thin.2
What to do when the letter arrives
- Read what's asked and when it's due. If you need more time, tell the officer early. HMRC may agree to extra time where there's a good reason.1
- Pick one person to deal with HMRC. You can authorise an adviser to act for you, and HMRC will copy them in on its letters.1
- Get the engineers who did the work to explain it. The questions are about technology, not tax, and a plain answer from the person who solved the problem beats a polished one written around them.
- Check the claim against HMRC's list of common errors before you reply. If something's wrong, tell HMRC straight away. HMRC reduces penalties most for companies that tell it, help it work out the right figure and give it access to what it asks for.1
- Keep filing and paying. Returns and payments that fall due during the check still need to go in on time.1
When a client gets one of these letters, we start by reading the AIF and the claim schedule against HMRC's questions, project by project, before anyone replies. It's the fastest way to see which answers are already on file and which need the engineers.
How a check ends
At the end, HMRC either sends one or more decision notices (an amended assessment, a penalty notice or a letter explaining the final position) or agrees a contract settlement with you.1 If HMRC and the company can't agree whether a project is R&D, the normal course is to close the enquiry once every other point's settled, ideally with a statement of agreed facts, and you can then appeal the amended assessment.2
You'll usually have 30 days from HMRC's letter to do one of three things: send the officer new information to take into account, ask for a review by an HMRC officer who hasn't been involved, or take the appeal to the independent tribunal. For some disputes, HMRC also offers Alternative Dispute Resolution, where a specialist officer acts as a neutral facilitator.1
If the claim was wrong
If you're still within the time limit to amend the Company Tax Return, amend it. If you're past it and owe HMRC money, use the R&D disclosure service. It covers up to 4 years if the company took reasonable care, or up to 6 if it was careless, and you'll usually get a payment reference within 15 calendar days. If the over-claim was deliberate, that service isn't for you: it's the Contractual Disclosure Facility instead. HMRC warns that waiting for it to contact you can mean extra interest and penalties.5
Why there are fewer claims to check
HMRC's September 2026 statistics put R&D claims for 2024-25 at 40,325, down 17% on the year before, and HMRC believes a key driver is the continuing impact of the Additional Information Form, mandatory for claims submitted from 8 August 2023.6 The relief claimed still rose, by 5% to £8.2 billion. The year-by-year series and the sector split are in our R&D Tax Relief Usage Index, and the state support for tech index shows how R&D relief sits next to grants and other support for UK tech companies.
Getting the next claim right
The cheapest compliance check is the one your claim's built to survive. Three things make the difference:
- Notify on time if you need to. First-time claimants, and companies whose last claim was made more than 3 years before their notification period ends, have to notify HMRC in a window that closes 6 months after the period of account ends, or the claim's invalid. For claims made from 1 April 2027 the notification is due to be scrapped (announced at Budget 2026, still to pass in the Finance Bill). Our guide to the notification deadline works through the dates.
- File the AIF first. It goes before or on the same day as the CT600, form first. Without it HMRC won't accept the claim, and if the return gets there first, the claim's rejected.
- Claim project by project. Build the claim from the projects that sought an advance, and the people and costs on them, not from the payroll down. Check the route as well: for periods beginning on or after 1 April 2024 most companies claim the merged scheme, and loss-making, R&D-intensive companies may get more under ERIS.
An SME claiming for the first time can also ask HMRC for advance assurance, which covers the whole claim for its first 3 accounting periods. And eligible SMEs, not only first-time claimants, can use a targeted version on up to 2 areas of a claim, which HMRC is piloting until May 2027. If you've had a letter, or you're about to claim and want it built to stand up, speak to us early. Software and SaaS founders can find more on our page for software development companies, and run indicative numbers with the R&D relief estimator.
Sources
- HMRC, About compliance checks: CC/FS1a (updated 30 April 2025).
- HMRC, CIRD80520: R&D tax relief: examining a claim: introduction (updated 7 August 2024).
- HMRC, CIRD80525: Practice note for ISBC and WMBC (updated 29 October 2026).
- HMRC, CIRD80530: examining a claim: risks and CIRD80540: examining a claim: common errors.
- HMRC, Tell HMRC if you've claimed too much R&D tax relief (updated 14 August 2026).
- HMRC, Research and Development Tax Credits Statistics: September 2026 (29 September 2026), and our derived R&D Tax Relief Usage Index. Published under the Open Government Licence v3.0. Data pulled 2026-11-04.